Should I Replace My AC Coil or Buy a New System?

An AC unit on white background.

The air conditioner coil, or evaporator coil, in your AC system is one of its most critical components. A failed evaporator coil is one of those difficult situations where you really need to consider whether the repair is worth the cost involved.

Read on to learn more about whether a new evaporator coil is a good investment for your Sanford, Florida, home.

What Is an Evaporator Coil & Why It Matters for Your AC System

If your air conditioner isn’t cooling properly, one of the most common causes is a problem with the evaporator coil. This vital component plays a major role in how your AC keeps your home cool and comfortable—so when it stops working, your entire system can feel like it’s failing.

In this guide, we’ll explain what an evaporator coil does, why it goes bad, and how to decide whether you should repair or replace it when something goes wrong.


What Does the Evaporator Coil Do?

The evaporator coil is a key part of your home’s cooling system. Located inside the indoor unit (usually with your furnace or air handler), the coil is filled with cold refrigerant. As warm air from your home blows across the coil, the refrigerant absorbs heat and humidity—leaving the air cooler and drier when it circulates back into your home.

So, if you’ve noticed your AC blowing warm air or your home staying hot and humid no matter how low you set the thermostat, your evaporator coil could be the culprit.


Common Signs of a Bad Evaporator Coil

Not sure if your AC coil is the problem? Here are a few symptoms of a failing evaporator coil:

  • AC not blowing cold air
  • Warm or humid air coming from vents
  • Frozen evaporator coil or ice buildup on the indoor unit
  • Strange hissing or bubbling noises near the air handler
  • Refrigerant leaks or low refrigerant levels
  • Increased energy bills without increased usage

If you notice any of these signs, call a professional HVAC technician right away. Ignoring the problem can lead to bigger system failures and more costly repairs.


Why Evaporator Coils Fail

Like any part of your air conditioner, the evaporator coil can wear out over time. With regular maintenance, it can last up to 15–20 years, but certain issues can shorten its lifespan:

  • Refrigerant erosion: As refrigerant moves through the coil and changes temperature, it can slowly wear away the interior lining.
  • External corrosion: Dirt, moisture, and airborne chemicals (like those from household cleaners) can damage the outside of the coil.
  • Physical damage: Impact from debris or poor installation can crack or dent the coil, leading to leaks and inefficiency.

Coils are built to withstand regular use—but over time, corrosion and wear can cause them to leak refrigerant or freeze up, leaving you without cold air.


Should You Repair or Replace Your AC Evaporator Coil?

The evaporator coil is one of the most expensive parts of an air conditioner. In many cases, replacing the coil can cost nearly as much as replacing the entire system—especially if your unit is already more than 10 years old.

Here’s how to decide whether evaporator coil replacement or new AC installation is the better option:

Choose Replacement If:

  • Your system is newer and under warranty
  • The coil is the only part that’s damaged
  • Your technician confirms the rest of the unit is in good condition

Consider a Full System Upgrade If:

  • Your system is 10+ years old
  • The repair cost is more than half the price of a new AC
  • You want improved energy efficiency or better indoor comfort

Benefits of upgrading your air conditioner may include:

  • Lower monthly energy bills with a higher SEER rating
  • More consistent comfort with features like variable-speed motors
  • Better humidity control and air quality
  • Modern thermostat compatibility and smart features

How to Prevent Evaporator Coil Problems

The best way to avoid costly evaporator coil repairs is with regular HVAC maintenance. A professional tune-up each spring helps keep your coil clean, your refrigerant levels balanced, and your system running at peak efficiency. This not only extends the life of your evaporator coil but also keeps your entire AC system in top shape.


Need Help with Your AC Evaporator Coil?

If your air conditioner isn’t keeping your home cool, don’t wait—Del-Air’s certified HVAC technicians are ready to help. Whether you need a coils inspection, AC repair, or a new system recommendation, we’ll guide you through the process and get your comfort back fast.

Call us today or schedule service online to get started!

Schedule an AC tune-up annually with Del-Air Heating & Air Conditioning. Call us today to learn more and schedule your service.

Easy Financing

Same Day Approval Learn More
Have A Question For Us?
Review Image
Review Image
Our Reviews See What Your Neighbors Are Saying

We are so grateful that Del-Air took care of us. It was an easy initial call. They ran routine service/maintenance. In that appointment, Raymond showed us areas in our air units that needed addressing. He took his time and made sure he made a thorough inspection of all the equipment. And what a nice gentleman. We…

Corie L.

This is our second house using Del-Air and the value and service is why we come back. Our tech Reggie was fabulous! Above and beyond service, super nice, professional and thorough!

Suzanne S.

I have been using Del-Air for our home a/c concerns since purchasing our home 8-yrs ago. They have been and remain top- notch.

Bryan C.

Called at 9pm and they were at our house the next day at 9am. Thorough evaluation , great communication, and fixed our problem without a hard upsell for a whole new unit I. Honest service and I have great confidence with this company moving forward.

Matt G.

This was my first experience with Del-Air and they were prompt, professional, and knowledgeable. They were able to get me in on the same day for a maintenance visit, which I wasn’t expecting but very much appreciated. The office staff was pleasant and so was the technician that came out to service my air conditioners. Thanks…

Kenya D.

Davenport, FL